Ep 198 | Stacy Mitchell
Challenging Monopoly Power: Why Local Business is Better for People, the Planet, and Your Wallet
Description
Monopolistic business practices have been illegal in the United States for more than a century. Yet, monopoly power continues to accelerate in our modern commercial landscape. Large, powerful corporations edge out smaller businesses, often citing scale, “efficiency”, and lower costs as their reasons for success. But looking more closely reveals a reality that is far different. Small businesses are more cost-effective and deliver better results to the people they serve than giant corporations. Furthermore, they form the backbone of engaged and connected communities. So what is actually preventing small businesses (and communities) from flourishing, and what can individuals do today to build economic power in their communities?
In this episode, Nate is joined by economic writer and strategist, Stacy Mitchell, to explore how concentrated economic power shapes the health of towns and cities – from economic resilience to social connectedness. They unpack why big businesses actually deliver poorer, pricier results and more vulnerable supply chains, yet are able squeeze smaller businesses out of the market. Stacy also sheds light on the United States’ long history of breaking up monopolies through antitrust laws, and the policy developments in recent decades that have prevented their enforcement.
How do small businesses play an integral role in fostering resilient social capital? Why have we seen an increase in economic consolidation and inequality in the last several decades, and how can we reverse it? Finally, what practical steps can each of us take in our own communities to advance more localized economic systems that better serve people and the planet?
About Stacy Mitchell
Stacy Mitchell is a writer, strategist, and policy advocate. She is Co-Executive Director of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, an organization that for five decades has challenged the wisdom of neoliberalism and championed local, community-oriented models. She also serves on the board of the Maine Center for Economic Policy.
Additionally, Stacy is the author of Big-Box Swindle: The True Cost of Mega-Retailers and the Fight for America’s Independent Businesses. In 2016, she co-authored Amazon’s Stranglehold, an influential report that took a critical eye to the e-commerce giant. Congress cited her research on Amazon’s monopolization strategy in its investigation of Big Tech’s dominance in 2021 and her work informed the Federal Trade Commission’s antitrust lawsuit against the company in 2023. She has also worked extensively at the local level, helping communities craft policies that support local entrepreneurship and vibrant commercial districts.
In French, we have a motto that says that a simple drawing is often better than a long explanation. Jean-Marc Jancovici Carbone 4 President
That’s very understandable because with left atmosphere thinking, one of the problems is that you see everything as a series of problems that must have solutions. Iain McGilchrist Neuroscientist and Philosopher
We can’t have hundreds and hundreds of real relationships that are healthy because that requires time and effort and full attention and awareness of being in real relationship and conversation with the other human. Nate Hagens Director of ISEOF
This is the crux of the whole problem. Individual parts of nature are more valuable than the biocomplexity of nature. Thomas Crowther Founder Restor
Show Notes & Links to Learn More
Download transcriptThe TGS team puts together these brief references and show notes for the learning and convenience of our listeners. However, most of the points made in episodes hold more nuance than one link can address, and we encourage you to dig deeper into any of these topics and come to your own informed conclusions.
00:00 – Stacy Mitchell info + works, Institute for Local Self-Reliance (ILSR)
ILSR resources: Home Composting 101 Guide, Local Policy Action Toolkit, Antitrust Laws State Map, Community Guide to Broadband Opportunities
03:29 – Institute for Local Self-Reliance
04:11 – Supply chain disruptions during COVID
04:23 – COVID disruptions in the U.S. meat supply
04:33 – Baby formula plant went under, so shortages of baby formula nationwide
04:43 – Akira S. Mori, et al. – Response diversity determines the resilience of ecosystems to environmental change
08:26 – Our economic system is geared for efficiency and profits
08:40 – The Borg (Star Trek reference)
09:38 – Embeddedness of economy in society
11:48 – Christopher Conte – Small Business in U.S. History
11:58 – Stacy Mitchell – The Great Grocery Squeeze
12:41 – Strong local economies foster community cohesion
13:48 – Robert Lustig on TGS
14:58 – Early history of the U.S. Political Economy, Democracy requires decentralizing political and economic power, The Political Economy of Democratic Decentralization
15:18 – What ignited the Boston Tea Party, (More info)
16:21 – Stacy Mitchell – The Rise and Fall of the Word ‘Monopoly’ in American Life
16:30 – New Deal
17:13 – Modern decline of antitrust enforcement, Antitrust laws
17:39 – Robert Bork
18:06 – Robert Bork – The Antitrust Paradox
18:33 – Government subsidy, U.S. government has given hundreds of millions in subsidies to large corporations
24:33 – Tobacco tax, Anti-smoking campaigns
25:10 – Josh Farley on TGS: Roundtable, Episode 7, Episode 29, Episode 185
26:23 – ILSR study – small businesses outperform big companies
26:43 – Independent pharmacies declining
27:08 – North Dakota banned corporations from owning pharmacies
27:53 – Dahlheimer & Mitchell – The Benefits of North Dakota’s Pharmacy Ownership Law
29:08 – Pharmacy benefit managers (PBM)
29:46 – 3 PBMs control over 80 percent of all prescriptions filled in the U.S., including the largest PBM, CVS
30:32 – PBMs under-reimbuse independent pharmacies
32:28 – ~90% of the pharmaceutical ingredients are imported from China and India
32:48 – U.S. has 4.5% of world’s population and 50% of the worldwide pharmaceutical market share
35:23 – Effects of consolidation on the economy
35:28 – Walmart captures 1 out of every 4 dollars Americans spend on groceries
37:52 – In 1980s, nearly half of all economic activity was happening among businesses with less than 100 employees (pg 15), Now down to about 20 percent
38:13 – Walmart and the next 3 biggest chains holds about 60% monopoly on all U.S. food sales
38:20 – The great consolidation of banking in the U.S.
38:48 – 4 U.S. megabanks hold almost half of all banking assets
39:03 – *78% of US beer grocery market is held by 4 firms
39:44 – Market cannibalism
41:43 – Fiscal consolidation impacts income inequality
42:38 – Amazon transformation of warehouse sector, Injury rates significantly higher than other warehouses
43:53 – 1940s-60s: a period of middle class expansion – rising level of high paying (union) jobs and rising levels of small businesses, (More info)
48:43 – Revival of antitrust under Biden
48:54 – Monopolization lawsuit filed against Amazon
49:21 – Amazon didn’t have to collect sales tax for many years
49:33 – Early subsidies given to Amazon
49:53 – Amazon penalizing small marketplace sellers
50:11 – Over the last 10 years Amazon takes a 20% cut to about 50%
51:23 – Many sellers on Amazon are based overseas
52:18 – As Amazon has become more dominant, consumer prices have gone up
52:30 – Amazon search results pages are increasingly ads, Amazon junk ads
53:00 – European countries also struggle with Amazon monopoly to lesser extent, Europe rarely enforces their antitrust laws
54:23 – Amazon avoids significant taxes
56:28 – Americans struggle to afford basic goods
56:41 – Documented lack of innovation in the U.S., Brittle supply chains
59:03 – U.S. broadband monopolization
59:28 – ILSR work building out community-owned broadband networks
59:48 – Benefits of local broadband
1:00:03 – North Dakota internet services
1:00:28 – Railroads contributed to development of early antitrust laws
1:00:48 – History of Standard Oil monopoly
1:03:33 – ILSR grassroots level work
1:05:03 – ILSR state/policy level work
1:06:48 – Zoning laws as tool to limit commercial development and create habitat for local businesses
1:07:23 – States have full authority over antitrust laws
1:07:43 – California, D.C., and Arizona have all filed monopolization lawsuits against Amazon, 17 states signed onto federal case
1:08:08 – Kroger-Albertsons attempted merger
1:08:41 – States are primary actors for policies surrounding electricity system
1:12:48 – ILSR North Tulsa grocery stores success story
1:15:43 – ILSR Tribal broadband bootcamp work
1:22:01 – Nearly 40 million Americans live in places without a grocery store
1:22:38 – History of ‘Food Deserts’ in the U.S.
